Harvard Journal on Legislation

Since 1964


Harvard Journal on Legislation

Since 1964

  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Contact JOL
    • Subscriptions
    • Copyright
    • Bylaws
    • Subscriptions
  • Executive Board and Staff
    • Volume 60 Masthead
    • Volume 59 Masthead
    • Volume 58 Masthead
    • Volume 57 Masthead
    • Volume 56 Masthead
    • Volume 55 Masthead
    • Volume 54 Masthead
    • Past Mastheads
  • JOL Online
    • All JOL Online
    • JOL Online Notes
    • Commentary
  • Archive
    • Volume 59, Number 2
    • Volume 59, Number 1
    • Volume 58, Number 2
    • Volume 58, Number 1
    • Volume 57, Number 2
    • Volume 57, Number 1
    • Volume 56, Number 2
    • Volume 56, Number 1
    • Volume 55, Number 2
    • Volume 55, Number 1
    • Volume 54, Number 2
    • Volume 54, Number 1
    • Volume 53, Number 2
    • Volume 53, Number 1
  • Symposia
    • 2022 Symposium: Polarized Then, Polarized Now
    • 2019 Symposium: Regulating Social Media
    • 2018 Symposium: Electoral Redistricting: Present and Future
    • 2018 Symposium: Policy in Motion: Infrastructure and Legal Architecture
    • 2016 Symposium: Privacy in the Digital Age: The Surveillance State and Personal Data
    • 2015 Symposium: Firearms in America: Safety and Liberty
    • 2014 Symposium: Drug Policy: Reality and Reform
    • 2013 Symposium: Class in America
    • 2012 Symposium: Government Outsourcing and Privatization
  • Submissions

I Spy: The Problems with NSA Overreach

February 5, 2014 by wpengine

I Spy: The Problems with NSA Overreach

Tyler Anderson[*]

 

Over the past several months, Congress has generated considerable outrage regarding the NSA’s collection of data from foreign officials.[2] Some of this criticism is surely deserved; for example, we recently learned that the NSA spied on Ban Ki-moon’s talking points before Ban’s meeting with President Obama to discuss, among other things, global climate change[3]—Moon is not the sort of existential threat toward which the NSA should be dedicating its resources.

Nevertheless, the outrage generated by international spying domestically—and particularly by Congress—largely misses the problems generated by NSA surveillance that is both secret and expansive. Here, the history of intelligence surveillance reform is instructive. The original Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act and the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act Amendments Act (FAA) strongly distinguished between surveillance conducted on foreigners compared to surveillance conducted on Americans.[4] While some of this tailoring is due to Constitutional (primarily 4th Amendment) constraints, it is important to remember that Congress put the policy of limiting surveillance overreach into play as a direct response to the unauthorized wiretapping of non-violent civic activists and other egregious behavior by the intelligence community against American citizens.[5]

In an overly punitive criminal justice system where the typical American commits up to three felonies a day,[6] information gathered by an NSA that can always make credible arguments that its power must be expanded to prevent the next terrorist attack,[7] gives the United States government enormous power that could be leveraged against every American. This is a problem that Angela Merkel and Dilma Rousseff don’t have to worry about.

(I say this while acknowledging that there are many measures the United States government can bring to bear against non-U.S. citizens that can make life very unpleasant for them. Hat tip, Ted Weisman.)


[*] J.D. Candidate, Harvard Law School, 2014.

[2] See Jack Goldsmith, Skepticism about Supposed White House and Intelligence Committee Ignorance About NSA Collection Against Allied Leaders, Lawfare (Oct. 29, 2013, 12:01 PM), https://www.lawfareblog.com/skepticism-about-supposed-white-house-and-intelligence-committee-ignorance-about-nsa-collection [https://perma.cc/TW28-QBBV].

[3] Scott Shane, No Morsel Too Miniscule for All-Consuming N.S.A., N.Y. Times (Nov. 2, 2013), https://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/03/world/no-morsel-too-minuscule-for-all-consuming-nsa.html [https://perma.cc/7D3Y-TFCK].

[4] See generally Tyler C. Anderson, Toward Institutional Reform of Intelligence Surveillance: A Proposal to Amend the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, 8(2) Harv. L. & Pol’y Rev. 413 (2014).

[5] See id.; see also Final Report of the Select Committee to Study Governmental Operations with Respect to Intelligence Activities, United States Senate (“Church Committee”), Report No. 94-755 (1976), available at https://www.intelligence.senate.gov/resources/intelligence-related-commissions [https://perma.cc/9YW2-FC8Y].

[6] See generally Harvey A. Silverglate, Three Felonies a Day: How the Feds Target the Innocent (2011).

[7] See Yochai Benkler, How the NSA and FBI foil weak oversight, The Guardian (Oct. 16, 2013), https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/oct/16/nsa-fbi-endrun-weak-oversight [https://perma.cc/56Y9-8ZPV].

Related

Filed Under: Featured Items, JOL Commentary, JOL Online Tagged With: featured

Students: Join our Mailing List!

Latest Print Issue: Volume 59, Number 2

Policy Essay

Pulling Back the Curtain on PBMs: A Path Towards Affordable Prescription Drugs by Representative Earl L. “Buddy” Carter

Articles

The Untapped Potential of the Congressional Review Act by Jody Freeman & Matthew C. Stephenson

Prepaid Death by Victoria J. Haneman

Captive Generics: The Wolf in Sheep’s Clothing by Robin Feldman

Note

Occupational Licensing: The Path to Reform Through Federal Courts and State Legislatures by Tzirel Klein

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
Students: Join our Mailing List!

Latest Print Issue: Volume 59, Number 2

Policy Essay

Pulling Back the Curtain on PBMs: A Path Towards Affordable Prescription Drugs by Representative Earl L. “Buddy” Carter

Articles

The Untapped Potential of the Congressional Review Act by Jody Freeman & Matthew C. Stephenson

Prepaid Death by Victoria J. Haneman

Captive Generics: The Wolf in Sheep’s Clothing by Robin Feldman

Note

Occupational Licensing: The Path to Reform Through Federal Courts and State Legislatures by Tzirel Klein

Tweets by HarvardJOL
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn

Copyright © 2023 · Outreach Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in